Advertisement. Advertise with us

Judge Coccoma Tells City, Town

To Negotiate Temporary Fire Pact

City Attorney David Merzig addresses Supreme Court Judge Michael V. Coccoma during this morning's hearing on the town and city fire contract. (Ian Austin/
City Attorney David Merzig addresses Supreme Court Judge Michael V. Coccoma during this morning’s hearing on the town and city fire contract. (Ian Austin/


COOPERSTOWN – A state Supreme Court judge this morning ordered the City of Oneonta and Town of Oneonta Fire District #1 to negotiate an extension to the current contract so the Oneonta Fire Department can continue protecting homes and businesses after midnight Dec. 31.

“It’s not the role of the court to negotiate a contract,” said Judge Michael V. Coccoma.  “But I’ll make myself available.”

During the hour-long hearing in Supreme Court chambers at the Otsego County Annex Building, both City Attorney David Merzig and Terence Hannigan, attorney for the town Fire Commissioners, presented their arguments.

“We’re trying to resolve this,” said Hannigan.  “But they are a vendor, and now they want 30 percent more or they won’t provide service.  The commissioners have an obligation to provide service, but they also have an obligation to show what tax dollars are being used for.”

“Our concern is that the commissioners have not fulfilled their one job, to provide fire coverage for the city,” said Merzig.  “911, EMS have told us that they haven’t been contacted by the town to change their vendor, so if a call comes through, it will be directed to us, and without a contract, we have no authority to respond to a fire in the town.  But if we don’t respond, we’re putting lives and property at risk.”

The town has not negotiated with another vendor, Hannigan said, and would rely on the county’s mutual aid agreement in the case of a fire.  “We’re not playing chicken with public safety,” he insisted.  “The city responds to mutual aid calls from the West Oneonta fire department without a contract.”  

But Merzig said that plan would not work.  “There has to be a primary response department to provide mutual aid to,” he said.  “We can’t have a mutual aid agreement with ourselves.”

Coccoma offered use the court’s conference rooms for both parties to concur with fire commissioners and council members not in attendance in hopes of bringing about a temporary resolution, with the stipulation that any contract would have to be approved by Common Council.

This is a developing story, please check back later for details


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Related Articles

Charter Review Committee Meets

The Charter Review Committee of the Oneonta Common Council met on Thursday, July 20 to discuss potential changes to the city’s governing document. Chairman Scott Harrington (R-6th Ward) and members Len Carson (R-5) and Kaytee Lipari Shue (D-4) met with City Attorney David Merzig to discuss a potential amendment that would allow a majority of the Common Council to remove members of boards and commissions.…

Common Council Agrees To 45 Day Fire Contract Extension

Common Council OKs Extension Of Fire Pact Until Valentine’s Day By LIBBY CUDMORE • for ONEONTA – With less than 72 hours before the expiration of its fire contract Town of Oneonta Fire District #1, Common Council this afternoon voted to extend the contract 45 days, as recommended by state Supreme Court Judge Michael V. Coccoma at last Thursday’s hearing. “It’s unfortunate that this is how we have to do business,” said Mayor Gary Herzig during the special meeting.  “But I’m confident that the new council will see that we’re compensated appropriately for the service we provide.” Coccoma said he will help with…

Pending Council Approval Town, City Agree to Extension

Town, Mayor Agree To Extend Fire Pact Special Common Council Meeting Called COOPERSTOWN – Mayor Gary Herzig and the Town of Oneonta Fire Commissioners today agreed to extend the town fire district’s current contract until Valentine’s Day, pending approval at a special Common Council meeting to be announced after Christmas. Herzig spoke to seven of the eight council members and reported that the majority of them said they would vote in favor of approving the extension.  During that time, the city and town will meet to continue negotiations for a longer contract, which will be retroactive to Jan. 1, 2016. Supreme…