News of Otsego County

Serving Otsego County, NY, through the combined reporting of Cooperstown's Freeman's Journal and the Hometown Oneonta newspapers.


Paul Agoglia

If Path To Renewables Wrong, So What? No Harm Is Done

If Path To Renewables Wrong,

So What? No Harm Is Done

To the Editor:

Mr. Downey and Mr. Zagata, apparent experts in fracked gas, and I (pro renewable) will not be here in 50 years to say to one another, “I told you so”.  Therefore it makes sense for us to ensure there is a future that includes four changes of season per year for posterity and for wildlife in Otsego County.

While both Downey and Zagata tout gas, and recently attempted to show negatives of renewables, neither made an attempt to paint a true picture of their buddy down in Pennsylvania, fracked gas.

There are well over 500 new “fracking ponds” scattered across northern and western Pennsylvania.  Looking like a bad case of acne on a clear face, they are illustrated on easy to obtain maps.

The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) does not keep a list of where these ponds are.  I wonder if that is by design or due to a lack of oversight staff?

Many ponds contain chemical waste.  While it appears that these “ponds” are eventually “cleaned up,” there are no signs telling wildlife which ponds to avoid.

If you were around for the acid rain issues in the 1970s and 1980s, you know how hard it is for wildlife to tell us there is an issue, other than laying belly up.

It can also be difficult to pinpoint the culprit – in the acid rain case, it was soot from coal-burning smoke stacks in the industrial Midwest that was impacting the lakes of the Adirondacks.

No one can claim to have a crystal ball that will tell him/her that the geology of Pennsylvania is permanently stable for eons to come, and therefore, that it is safe to frack in Pennsylvania.

Remember Pangea from Earth Science?  Things move!  Surprise!

There are indications of apparent health-related issues being reported already, less than a decade into fracking.  How about a neighbor to a fracking site who decides he/she wants/needs to put in a new water well.  Will they hit clean water or contaminated water?  Will the well have to be monitored permanently to be on the safe side?  Who picks up the cost long after the frackers are gone?

Why would anyone in Otsego County, New York want us to contribute to Pennsylvania’s developing geological nightmare by buying in?  Solar and wind are currently at a levelized cost equal to if not better than that of electricity from natural gas fired power plants.

Geothermal as indicated by Jay Egg appears ripe to give gas a run for the money as a heat source.  You want jobs? Well let’s consider laying geothermal pipe!

The secret issue with natural and fracked gas that no Democrat, Republican or gas-industry representative wants to talk about is methane.

Based on an MIT study done almost 10 years ago, all that is needed is a 3 percent loss of natural gas anywhere along the pipe (the frack well, frack site, CNG truck, decompressor station, destination site) and then natural gas is worse than coal for the environment.  All this because of the impact a small amount of escaping methane has in the air.

We have two paths we can choose from that I am aware of.  Gas will keep us toasty warm for years, but if gas climate deniers are wrong, they leave us no “out.”  And you always want an “out” or “mulligan.”

If the renewable path is taken and climate scientists are wrong, well, we then happily take our mulligan and life goes on.




Railyards Derail State of City Speech

Railyard Woes Derail

State-Of-City Speech

Paul Agoglia, Oneonta, urges Mayor Gary Herzig to install fast-charge stations for electric cars and to work with local farmers for solar and wind energy for the D&H  railyards, rather than gas, as 125 people showed up for the public comment period on the railyards’ GEIS following the Mayor Gary Herzig’s State of the City address this evening at Foothills Performing Arts Center, all but a few calling for green energy in the proposed project.  The outpouring of comment derailed plans to announce $2 million in grants for downtown upgrades, the first flowering of the city’s DRI program; the list was left on a counter in the lobby of Foothills’ black-box theater.  (Ian Austin/



RoboKronos Founder To Retire, Honored By Team

RoboKronos Honors

Departing Founder

Paul Agoglia, center right, is applauded by members of the FIRST Robotics Team as Skip Copperwheat presents him with an award in recognition to his founding, mentoring and leading of the RoboKronos Team 4203. The award came after Agoglia announced that he would be retiring from leading the team at the end of the school year. Agoglia, founded the robotics group through 4H in 2007 and by 2011, the team had gained sponsors and become and official FIRST Robotics team. The team, comprised of 19 students and mentors, continues to enjoy popularity and and go to competitions. (Ian Austin/


Posts navigation

21 Railroad Ave. Cooperstown, New York 13326 • (607) 547-6103