Advertisement. Advertise with us

Around State,
‘Microgrids’ Require
Gas From Fracking

To the Editor:
In his recent response about a microgrid for the railyard, Albert Colone faulted me for not giving him credit for a source of energy that he never mentioned in his original article: biomass. Then he asks who, besides me, would not like that?
Well, the hundreds of people who vigorously opposed and ultimately defeated a proposed wood-burning power plant in the railyards a few years ago would probably say, “No thank you, Albert.”
Clearly, I must repeat the lesson of my earlier letter regarding “combined heat and power” (CHP), also called “cogeneration.” CHP requires combustion to create electricity and heat at the same time.
Consequently, it won’t work very well as a “backup” electricity source unless heat is also needed during those periods of peak demand.
As I wrote earlier, geothermal energy would be a great way of heating and cooling buildings at the railyards or elsewhere: I support that 100 percent. However, unless we move to Iceland where geysers are hot enough to run turbines, geothermal is not a CHP solution.
If, instead of “biomass,” Mr. Colone actually meant “biogas,” then he will need to relocate his CHP power plant, and the industrial-development area, to the county landfill. Otherwise, he will need a very long steam tunnel.
There is only one hydro-powered microgrid proposed under NYSERDA’s New York Prize initiative, and I would support such a plan for Oneonta if it were deemed feasible.
But every other microgrid that has been proposed or built in New York produces almost all its energy by burning fracked gas.
A 25 MW CHP power plant at the railyards would need a dozen so-called “bomb trucks” a day for fuel. Of course, a few watt-hours of wind or solar electricity might be tossed in as window-dressing, but that won’t solve the climate crisis.
The bottom line is that more combustion means more greenhouse gas emissions.
We are out of time for “all of the above” solutions that make us more dependent on fossil fuels.

DENNIS HIGGINS
Otego

Posted

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Related Articles

MORE LETTERS ENDORSE FOR CCS SCHOOL BOARD

MORE LETTERS ENDORSE FOR CCS SCHOOL BOARD ST. JOHN: Jastremski Devoted To Youth KATZ: Jastremski Transformed Library ALLSTADT:  Jastremski Intelligent, Worker WALKER:  Markusen Will Communicate…

HAPPENIN’ OTSEGO for FRIDAY, JULY 21

HAPPENIN’ OTSEGO for FRIDAY, JULY 21 Elvis Costello At Ommegang CONCERT – 5 p.m. Elvis Costello & The Imposters perform live. Show starts at 7 p.m. Brewery Ommegang, Cooperstown. www.ommegang.com/#!events HISTORY READING – 7:30 p.m. Hear the letters of soldiers of the Civil War as ready by Wanda Burch, accompanied by original music written and performed by John Kenosian. Experience their loneliness, homesickness, and hope for survival. Windfall Dutch Barn, 2009 Clinton Rd., Cherry Valley. www.windfalldutchbarn.com…

HAPPENIN’ OTSEGO for MONDAY, FEBRUARY 17, 2020

HAPPENIN’ OTSEGO for MONDAY, FEBRUARY 17 ‘Step Afrika’ Dance Performance PRESIDENTS DAY! PERFORMANCE – 9 – 10:30 p.m. ‘Step Afrika’ performs dance that uses the human body as an instrument as practiced by traditionally African American fraternities, sororities and incorporates song, story telling, audience participation. Admission, $3/person. Hunt Union Ballroom, SUNY Oneonta.…