Advertisement. Advertise with us

Chef Jordan Tolley, Dave Baldo and Kelly Tolley of Fatboyz Pizza and Badazz Bitez and a frequent customer, Brandon Johnson (standing). (Photo by Monica Calzolari)

Shop Name May Be Unusual, But the Faces Are Familiar

By MONICA CALZOLARIONEONTA

We ran out of pizza dough our first day in business,” laughed Kelly Tolley of Fatboyz Pizza and Badazz Bitez.

They opened with a soft launch a month ago, on August 2. Word of mouth spread so fast that Jordan Tolley, his mom Kelly, and Dave Baldo, whom Jordan calls dad, could not keep up with the demand.

Laughter seems to be the secret ingredient in this family-owned business. Family members crack jokes and share their enthusiasm from the minute you meet them.

Fatboyz Pizza is named for Kelly’s brother, Dave Wright, who died prematurely 12 years ago in his early 40s. Dave’s nickname was Fatboy. He had a beer belly.

Jordan came up with the idea of naming the business after his uncle. When they went to register that name with New York State, Fatboys Pizza was already taken and the state said they were not allowed to use “Badass” in the name.

So they decided to spell their name with several z’s in order to get their DBA registered.

Although they had just opened, Chef Jordan closed the pizza shop from August 31 through September 1 for the 12th Annual Biker Bash, a charity they launched in honor of Uncle Dave Wright.

You have reached your limit of 3 free articles

To Continue Reading

 

Our hard-copy and online publications cover the news of Otsego County by putting the community back into the newspaper. We are funded entirely by advertising and subscriptions. With your support, we continue to offer local, independent reporting that is not influenced by commercial or political ties.

Posted

Related Articles

Competition Engages Community in Addressing Food Insecurity

On Saturday, April 18, 10 local teams assembled their structures made of cans, water bottles and Chobani yogurt containers inside Southside Mall. Their artistic creations will be on display until Sunday, April 26, before being donated to local food pantries throughout Otsego County.…
April 23, 2026

RSS Addresses Misunderstandings, Questions about Housing Project

“Our mission is to address the housing shortage for Oneontans first, while still complying with Fair Housing law,” according to Nealon. “All outreach during lease-up will be widely marketed within Oneonta and Otsego County so that local residents are well-informed and encouraged to apply.”…
March 12, 2026

Turnout Strong for Recent Public Hearing on Second RSS Housing Project Proposal

Ed Bixley of River Street spoke to the Planning Commission on Feb. 24 at Riverside Elementary School regarding the proposed RSS project. (Photo by Monica Calzolari) Turnout Strong for Recent Public Hearing on Second RSS Housing Project Proposal By MONICA CALZOLARIONEONTA Approximately 100 local residents provided feedback for nearly two hours to the City of Oneonta Planning Commission at a public hearing on Tuesday, February 24 regarding the supportive housing complex that Rehabilitation Support Services proposes to build at 164 River Street in the Sixth Ward. This meeting took place in the Riverside Elementary School cafeteria. Planning Commission meetings on…
March 5, 2026

PUTTING THE COMMUNITY BACK INTO THE NEWSPAPER

For a limited time, subscribers to AllOtsego.com pay a reduced rate ($25.00 for one year) and can choose to have $5.00 of the subscription fee donated toward refurbishment of Otsego County’s Civil War Memorial.

Visit our “subscribe” page to sign up