News of Otsego County

Serving Otsego County, NY, through the combined reporting of Cooperstown's Freeman's Journal and the Hometown Oneonta newspapers.


Oneonta Hotel

Oneonta Hotel Due Back In Court

Oneonta Hotel

Due Back In Court

ONEONTA – Citing an insufficient building permit application, the City of Oneonta will once again bring the owners of the former Oneonta Hotel to court.

“The application did not even come close to remedying the deficiencies,” said Mayor Gary Herzig.

Weight Of Court Behind City Hall On Oneonta Hotel

Weight Of Court

Behind City Hall

On Oneonta Hotel

Fix It, Or Building Will Be Vacated,

Owner Held In Contempt, Judge Says

Attorney Ryan T. Donovan, of Harris, Conway & Donovan, Albany, center, confers with his client, Oneonta Hotel owner Melania Pervu, right. In the foreground is Pervu’s daughter, Nicoletta, and in the background, Oneonta City Attorney David Merzig. (Jim Kevlin/

By JIM KEVLIN • Special to

Melania Pervu

COOPERSTOWN – County Judge John Lambert this morning supported Oneonta City Hall’s actions against Oneonta Hotel owner Melania Pervu in every particular, only extending the deadline for final action until January.

After conferring with lawyers for both sides for 40 minutes in chambers, Lambert, filling in as Supreme Court judge for Michael V. Coccoma, on assignment out of town, declared:

• One, city building inspectors must provide Mrs. Pervu with a comprehensive list of violations by Oct. 1.





COOPERSTOWN – Acting state Supreme Court Judge John Lambert today affirmed Oneonta City Hall’s decision, telling Oneonta Hotel owner Melania Pervu a few minutes ago that she must bring the building up to code by Jan. 11, 2019, or it will be vacated and she will be held in contempt.


City Takes Hotel Owners To Court


Lawyer: City Hall Won’t

Take Blame For Deaths

By PARKER FISH • Special to

COOPERSTOWN – In the first court hearing in City Hall efforts to evict tenants from the deteriorating former Oneonta Hotel building, City Attorney David Merzig made the city’s opinion very clear.

The Building at 195 Main St. (Ian Austin/

“We’re at the end of our ropes,” Merzig said today in state Supreme Court here. “We are not going to be held responsible if there is a fire in that building and 20 people die in downtown Oneonta.”

After ordering  building owners Melania and Nicolae Pervu to fix multiple building code violations, the city deemed the building unsafe last November and stated that the Pervus had until April 30 to comply with the building codes before evictions would take place.

Merzig explained that those code violations were not rectified, and the city is looking to move forward with eviction proceedings as soon as possible.

“It is the city’s position that that ship has already sailed,” said Merzig, citing the nine-month window the city gave the owners.

EDITORIAL: It’s Decision Time. But Is There The Will?

Editorial, May 5, 2018

It’s Decision Time.

But Is There The Will?

Gary Herzig

Question: Can Oneonta Mayor Gary Herzig’s administration make tough decisions?
For one thing, whether or not to condemn the Twelve Tribes’ blighted Oneonta Ford property has been hanging fire since before Herzig took office. He’s now in his second term.
There is state money in hand to demolish what is a public hazard and state money to prepare the site for new construction. All that’s hanging fire is a tough decision.

Now, the April 30 deadline to clear out the venerable but – city inspectors have found – dangerous Oneonta Hotel is passed. Where’s the decision that’s been promised for months?
City Hall’s Board of Public Service declared the property unsafe in January 2017, 16 months ago. And still the building is occupied, and businesses are functioning on the ground floor.
You have to ask, what’s City Hall’s liability –and that of local taxpayers — if a fire or some other misfortune were to happen?
It’s past time to make a tough decision. Question: Can the Herzig Administration make it?
Question 2: Common Council has barely debated any issue publicly in months. Where are the Council members?

Declared ‘Unsafe,’ Oneonta Hotel To Be Vacated

Still Found ‘Unsafe,’

Hotel To Be Vacated

Following a declaration of “Unsafe,” the residents of the apartment in the former Oneonta Hotel are facing eviction. (Ian Austin/

By LIBBY CUDMORE • Special to

ONEONTA – After finding “numerous violations” remaining at the former Oneonta Hotel, 195 Main St., City Hall has begun the process of evicting the remaining tenants following the passing of the April 30 deadline imposed for fixing building deficiencies.

“After review of all inspection reports, it is clear that numerous violations still exist,” said Mayor Gary Herzig. “To protect the safety of the residents, general public, and our first responders, the city attorney is moving forward with vacating the building.”

Posts navigation

21 Railroad Ave. Cooperstown, New York 13326 • (607) 547-6103