Reprinted From This Week's 

Freeman's Journal & Hometown Oneonta

Innkeeper Asks: Did

Van Buren Sit HERE?

By LIBBY CUDMORE • Special to www.AllOTSEGO.com

CHERRY VALLEY – During home renovations, Barbara Hall and her husband, Gary Lozier, found where President Martin Van Buren likely sat when he visited the village in 1839.

Not a chair. A toilet seat.

“The whole back room was garbage,” she said of the former Story Tavern, now her refurbished home at 171 Main St. “As we were cleaning it out, we realized the outhouses were there.”

Following his election as president in 1837, Van Buren came through the village in September 1839 to meet with his constituents, following a similar reception in Cooperstown the day before.

“The Village had a reception at the Story Tavern and he certainly had some nice fare and something to drink,” she said. “Certainly, he used the outhouse.”