Advertisement. Advertise with us

Otego residents lament loss of local bank as Community closes branch

By KEVIN LIMITI • Special to

Community Bank has closed its branch in Otego, the only bank in the town, much to the dismay of residents and local leaders.

In a letter dated June 22, F.J. Buzz Hesse, chairman of the village of Otego Planning Board, Otego Mayor Ernest Kroll and Otego Town Supervisor Joseph Hurlburt asked Hal Wentworth, senior vice president of retail banking for Community Bank, to reconsider closing the branch.

“The intended closing of the Otego branch of Community Bank N.A. will be extremely detrimental to both the bank’s Otego customers and the village of Otego itself,” the letter said.

“In your letter, you state that with the closing of the Otego Branch, Community Bank, N.A. will ‘remain highly committed to our communities’ and will ‘effectively provide services to our customers.’ Surely, you must see that closing of the Otego branch demonstrates exactly the opposite. There is no commitment by Community Bank, N.A. to the Otego community that can possibly be perceived with the removal of your services from our community.”

Wentworth replied to this letter on July 2, saying although Community does not take closing the branch lightly they see the change as necessary “given trends in retail branch transactions and shifting customer behaviors.” Wentworth also said customers can continue to use the branch in Oneonta, which he
said was six miles away from the Otego branch.

A call to Wentworth for further comment was not returned.

Hulburt said he wasn’t optimistic about the prospect of Community Bank staying in Otego.

“I think it’s a done deal,” Hulbert said. “I don’t think they’re going to change their minds.”

Hesse called the closing of the bank a great loss for the community and said Community Bank was not forthcoming with its response.

“I think (the closing) is going to have a negative effect, not
necessarily on the community bank’s financial situation,” Hesse said, who called the presence of the bank an asset to the community where the workers were personable and familiar with Otego residents.

Hesse also said there had not been much communication from the bank after the letter was sent.

“I know numerous people who have made phone calls to the principal parties,” Hesse said, but there has been “no effort” made by Community Bank or Wentworth. He said the responses they got were “patronizing at best and certainly hypocritical.”

Hesse said he knew many people would be stopping their service with Community Bank including himself.

“It’s a loss to the community,” Hesse said.

Community Bank will also be consolidating its branch on Main Street in Cooperstown to its
location on Route 28 in the town of Otsego.



  1. My believe’s that it’s not fair to the community at all. I myself has used that Bank in the past and and on several occasions which was Very convenient for me. Something should be done about this, to accommodate the customers in the area.

  2. Shame on Community bank. I will close all my accounts with them. Sidney Federal Credit Union is on the way, before you get to the Chestnut St branch. You could cut the distance by a little. Sorry CBNA

  3. Main Street in Cooperstown is not welcoming to locals anymore. It might look pretty but it’s not functioning. Small towns everywhere are having a difficult time, but businesses have not been given top priority. Possibly an over abundance of baseball oriented shops and paid parking. Sad.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Related Articles

Hesse Home in Otego: a Virtual 18th-century House and Home Museum

Hesse Home in Otego: a Virtual 18th-century House and Home Museum By TERESA WINCHESTEROTEGO For 33 years, Buzz Hesse, a trained archeologist and former owner of the auction house Hesse Galleries, has lived with his wife, Jackie, in a house built in the late 18th century. He loves to tell the story of how he first spotted the structure in Laurens, later purchased it, then disassembled it, and ultimately found an ideal site for the house in Otego.The moment he saw the “unpretentious-looking” two-story house, he wanted it, despite the horse standing in the doorway and the chickens running in…

Community Bank in Morris To Close

Within the past two years, Community Bank has also closed branches in Otego, Milford, Schenevus, Downsville and Fleischmanns.…

In Memoriam: Mary S. Carson

OTEGO—Our beloved Mary (Shultis) Carson, 89, of Otego, New York, died peacefully at home on November 22, 2023. While we miss her dearly, her light and her love will shine on in our hearts.
Mary was born in Oneonta on June 6, 1934 to Gertrude (Champlin) and Francis Edmund Shultis. A lifetime resident of Otego, she graduated from Otego Central School in 1952. Mary met the love of her life, John Carson, when they were juniors in high school, and they married on September 13, 1952. Seventy-one years later, John will tell you that he chose her then and he would choose her today. Together, they raised four children, all educated in the Otego area.…