Advertisement. Advertise with us


Republicans Pass

Resolution Against

‘Green Light Bill’

Stammel Sole Democrat To Oppose

Driver’s Licenses For Illegal Aliens

By JENNIFER HILL • Special to

County Clerk
Kathy Sinnott Gardner

COOPERSTOWN – With only one Democrat supporting the 8-3-3 vote, the Otsego County Board of Representatives today sent a resolution to the state Assembly opposing the so-called “Green Light Bill” allowing illegal immigrants to obtained drivers’ licenses.

Voting aye were Republicans Ed Frazier of Unadilla, Kathy Clark of Otego, Peter Oberacker of Schenevus, Dan Wilber of Burlington, Keith McCarty of East Springfield and board Chair David Bliss of Cooperstown/Town of Middlefield, as well as Meg Kennedy, C-Mount Vision.  Andrew Stammel, Town of Oneonta, was the sole Democrat joining them.

Voting nay were Democrats Gary Koutnik, Danny Lapin and Adrienne Martini, all of Oneonta.  Abstaining were Democrats Michelle Farwell of Morris, Andrew Marietta of Cooperstown/Town of Otsego, and Liz Shannon of Oneonta

Resolution 175 expresses opposition to the proposed the Driver’s License Access & Privacy Act, which would not require people seeking licenses to show proof of U.S. citizenship.  The bill passed the state Senate and is awaiting action in the Assembly.

State Sen. Jim Seward, R-Milford, today said Senate Republicans “vehemently opposed” the Democratic initiative.

“The thought of giving a driver’s license, a secure identification document, to someone who is intentionally breaking the law is inconceivable,” he said. “This measure is bad public policy that would put lives in danger, reward lawbreakers, and send the wrong message to those who take the legal path to citizenship.”

Introducing Resolution 175, Kennedy said County Clerk Kathy Sinnott Gardner, who administers the local DMV office, had asked for it because the clerk’s office would be tasked with determining how the county would comply with the law.  Kennedy worried “the right to vote would be eroded” if the state bill was signed into law.

An illegal immigrant can register to vote by pressing a “yes” or “no” button while going through the steps to obtain a drivers’ license. “Nothing right now can stop an undocumented worker from pressing ‘yes’,” said Kennedy.

The state County Clerks Association has spearheaded opposition to the measure.

Voting against Resolution 175, Koutnik said, “One million workers are undocumented in New York, more than five percent of the labor force. A quarter of them lives outside the city with no access to public transportation.” Allowing them to get licenses would also generate more fees, he said.

Stammel said he’s “not a big fan of the resolution,” saying it attracts demagoguery, but that he voted for it to support the county clerk and other employees.

Kennedy said if the bill passes the Senate and is signed into law, Otsego County will have to implement it.  But in passing Resolution 175, Otsego County can let “our legislators know how we feel about it.”

Copies will be sent to the four Republican Assemblymen who represent the county – John Salka, Brookfield, Brian D. Miller, New Hartford, Chris Tague, Schoharie, and Clifford Crouch, Bainbridge.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Related Articles

Satellite DMV Space: Progress or Just a Ploy?

Early voting began Saturday, October 28 and Election Day itself is just five days away from this paper’s publication date. Benton and his supporters are crying foul after Basile’s announcement, contending this is just a last-minute campaign ploy—that she has not gone through the proper channels to make such a claim, nor have costs associated with the satellite office been included in the county’s 2024 budget.…

Editorial: Who Will You Choose?

Election Day is just 19 days away and early voting starts October 28. If you’re like us, your head is swimming with questions about the race for Otsego County clerk. Experience and departmental knowledge versus energy and vision. Republican versus Democrat. Jennifer Basile versus MacGuire Benton.…

Sinnott Gardner: Experience Vital to Clerk Position

On two weeks ago, Mr. Benton discusses speeding up the process of filing and recording documents to improve customer service. His response was proof to me how little he knows about the county clerk’s office.…