News of Otsego County

Otsego County Courthouse

Dylan Robinson sentenced to 20 years to life for murder in botched robbery
Dylan Robinson is led into the Otsego County Courthouse prior to his sentencing Monday, Oct. 4, in Cooperstown. (Kevin Limiti/

Dylan Robinson sentenced
to 20 years to life
for murder in botched robbery

By KEVIN LIMITI • Special to

COOPERSTOWN Dylan Robinson was sentenced to 20 years to life at the Otsego County Courthouse on Monday, Oct. 4, for the murder of his father, Kenneth Robinson, during a botched 2019 robbery attempt for marijuana and money.

Dylan was 15 when the crime was committed Oct. 10, 2019, in Worcester.

During sentencing, Otsego County Judge John Lambert said Robinson made “poor decisions in your young life” and noted Dylan smoked marijuana and alcohol daily and hung out with the wrong crowd.

Robinson murder trial goes to jury, verdict expected Wednesday
Dylan Robinson, right, appeared in Otsego County Court on Monday, June 21, to face charges that he murdered his father, Kenneth Robinson in 2019. (Kevin Limiti/

Robinson murder trial
goes to jury,
verdict expected Wednesday

By KEVIN LIMITI • Special to

COOERSTOWN — The second day of the Dylan Robinson trial at the Otsego County Courthouse ended Tuesday, June 22, with jury deliberations, after the prosecution rested and the defense chose not to submit any evidence.

Robinson is accused of allegedly killing his father, Kenneth Robinson, and burning his house after a failed robbery attempt. He is charged with second-degree murder, burglary and attempted robbery in the first degree and third-degree arson.

Tuesday morning testimony began with Cory Robinson, 14, who testified that he remembered the night of Oct. 10, 2019 “because that’s the day my dad died.”

Cory Robinson, 12 at the time, was awoken by gunshots in the house.

He said that armed people came in his home wearing blue bandannas and he recognized two of them as his brother Dylan Robinson and Alexander Borggreen. Someone pointed a gun at him and asked for his phone, so he gave it to them.

Afterwards, he and his brother, Aiden, were told to put pillows up to their faces and walked a short distance from the house. They were told to walk back and found their home in flames.

He found Kenneth Robinson’s body when he came back to the house. “When I took the pillow off, I saw my dad,” Cory Robinson said.

Hundreds Attend Rally To Protest Crimes Against Asian People

Hundreds Attend Rally In Rain To
Protest Crimes Against Asian People

By GREG KLEIN • Special to

The Agostino family displays its signs Sunday, May 2, at the Otsego Rally for Solidarity with Asian Americans at the Otsego County Courthouse in Cooperstown. (Greg Klein/

About 250 people attended a rally Sunday, May 2, at the Otsego County Courthouse, to support the community’s Asian American and Pacific Island residents.

The “Otsego Rally for Solidarity with Asian Americans” was organized and run by a group of Cooperstown Central School freshmen, including 15-year-old Cate Bohler, who said she wanted to speak up to support her friends or anyone who is being harassed.

“As a young Asian-American girl, hearing people call COVID the China virus is hurtful,” Bohler said, reading from her prepared statement about why she wanted to stage the rally. “It is more than hurtful. It is harmful. It perpetuates anti-American sentiments and racism.”

Speakers included the students, as well as local officials, including Cooperstown Mayor Ellen Tillapaugh, Cooperstown Police Chief Frank Cavalieri, Otsego Town Supervisor Meg Kiernan and Otsego County Rep. Danny Lapin, D-Oneonta, who said he thinks he is the county’s only elected official of Asian descent. Lapin’s mom is Japanese.

“The deep-seated nature of systemic racism requires us to make continuous choices and take continuous actions to advance anti-racist ideas in the public space,” Lapin said.




After Protest In Cooperstown,

Oneonta Mayor Wants Review

Last year, she met Pope Francis; last Sunday, Paula DiPerna was among 850 people at the “Rally for Justice for George Floyd” in front of the county courthouse in Cooperstown. (Jim Kevlin/

By JIM KEVLIN • Special to

After “Justice for George Floyd” rallies in Oneonta, then Cooperstown, the focus is turning from talk to action.

Organizers MacGuire Benton and Maria Noto confront a flag-waver they feared was an agitator.

Local chapter Vice President Michelle Osterhoudt advised Mayor Gary Herzig of the NAACP’s four-point “We Are Done Dying” program, including a ban on chokeholds, opening
police disciplinary records, and citizen review boards.

Paula DiPerna, the Cooperstown climate activist, said she has asked Mayor Ellen Tillapaugh Kuch and village trustees to adopt President Obama’s eight-point program to reduce violence against blacks.

“It’s a threshold,” said DiPerna after attending the Sunday, June 7, rally on the front lawn of the Otsego County Courthouse. “We need to dedicate ourselves in our personal lives and our professional lives to actually achieving some change.”

Attendees at the Sunday, June 7 “Rally for Justice” included the Pondolfinos, formerly of Oneonta: dad Tom, mom Amy and son Thomas.

Earlier this week, Herzig and Common Council member David Rissberger had already had a first conversation with OPD Chief Douglas Brenner about ensuring Oneonta policing
policies are everything they might be.

“This is a time for all of us to do a little introspection,” Herzig said, “and make sure our operating procedures and our policies are designed to do everything they can to guard against any inequality in how we treat the public.”

That first conversation occurred after the Cooperstown rally, where the OPD and other police agencies came in for criticism from six speakers:

• Oneonta’s Bryce Wood told how “my mother” – a school teacher – “heard that knock – bang, bang – at 2 a.m. one morning in 2000, and opened the door to a gun. For 30 minutes, they” – she and her husband, a state juvenile corrections officer – “were questioned at gunpoint. They thought we were drug dealers.”

Showing their official IDs allayed officers’ suspicions, but what if they had no IDs? The parents woke their 7-year-old son, told him what happened, and emphasized the danger he was in for just being black.

• Shannon McHugh, chairman, Oneonta Community Relations & Human Rights Commission, urged attendees to be “a second pair of eyes,” to stop and observe when police officers have pulled someone over. She recounted being in a car that was pulled over, and 10 officers showed up to search the car, only to find nothing.

Her 10-year-old daughter “wants to know why people who look like her mother are killing people like her dad,” said McHugh, who wants to make sure her daughter, for her own protection, is “the wokest girl in the world.”

• Lee Fisher, president, NAACP, Oneonta chapter, declared, “When George Floyd was on the ground and he asked to breath – air is free – he asked for the freedom to breath. I believe that God said, ‘George, your last breath is going to be for America’.”

What happened to Floyd was more than a single incident – it reflects the inability to earn a living wage, to get affordable housing or a good education, Fisher said. “People have to realize what’s going on is systemic,” he said. “It’s the system.”

• The Rev. LaDana Clark, founder of ChurchNtheHood who has preached at the Coopers-town Presbyterian Church, recounted an episode that began when she said hi to officers on exiting the Oneonta Walmart. After a sequence of events, “for the first time in my life, an officer put cuffs on me in Laurens, N.Y. I’m 58 years old. I was disgusted.”

Diandra Sangetti-Daniel, a personal care aide in Oneonta, and C.S. Brown, a local activist, also spoke, detailing complaints with Oneonta police and pointing out that all Civil Rights causes should be similarly allied against oppression.

Wes Lippitt, Fly Creek, thanks his “guardian angel” for saving his life when he was shot in 2010.

And Wesley Lippitt, Fly Creek, who was chased from Cooper Park and shot by a classmate on Good Friday 2010 thanked his “guardian angel” for allowing him to survive.

The Cooperstown event drew 850 people, up from 500 in Oneonta’s Muller Plaza Sunday, May 31, and 700 at the Delaware County Courthouse, Delhi, on Saturday, June 6. Another rally is planned 1-3 p.m. this Saturday, June 13, at Community Field in Unadilla.

One of the Cooperstown organizers, Maria Noto, CCS ’17, set the tone: “Police brutality is rooted in white supremacy. This needs to change.”

While Rev. LaDana was speaking, a young man, Austin Partridge of Milford, stationed himself next to the courthouse steps and unfurled an American flag.

The organizers approached him and asked him to move away, then – when press began to take photos – they formed a cordon around him to block the Stars & Stripes from the cameras. He was eventually convinced to go away.

“Listening to Rev. LaDana,” Partridge explained later, “it really resonated with me. I had the flag in my back pack. I wasn’t sure I was going to do anything. I felt what she was saying represented American values, that we are all created by God.”

Bryan Van Deusen, Oneonta, brought his pals Kiddo and Harlee to Sunday’s rally.

Once he unfurled the flag, “a lot of people were very upset about that. I understand where they were coming from, although I disagree with them. They wanted me to leave.
I was chanting no slogans, I was merely holding the American flag.”

Before he left, he sought out Rev. LaDana: “I told her it was an amazing speech.”

After reflecting on what happened for a few days, Benton said the organizers didn’t know what they were facing when Partridge unfurled the flag, whether he was there with “good intentions” or not.

“We didn’t tell him to get out,” he said. “We asked him to step away from the section where people were speaking. I just thought it was in poor taste.”

An estimated 850 people attended the “Justice for George Floyd” rally Sunday, June 7, at the Otsego County Courthouse in Cooperstown.

Benton, who is also a village trustee, objected to “the narrative that the co-organizers or Democratic politicians or people who support Black Lives Matter are somehow anti-American. I love America, (although) it doesn’t always live up to its promise.”

On where to go from here, Mayor Tillapaugh pointed out the Village Board has already passed a resolution declaring Cooperstown a “welcoming community” for all people.

Given the size of the police force right now – two officers, and one of them black, Terrell Silvera – the chances for problems raised at the rally are less than they might be, she said.

Still, the trustees are planning to hire a new police chief over the next several months, and that would be a good time to revisit the issue, she said.

At the county board level, Vice Chair Meg Kennedy, C-Hartwick, said the reps have been occupied with the financial devastation from the COVID-19 threat, and have
not yet focused on the unrest that followed.

Attendees interviewed after the latest rally thought it a worthwhile undertaking.

DiPerna, a Democratic congressional candidate in the 1990s, called it “a very moving and significant outpouring of support by the community of the idea we have to eliminate system racism and ‘white silence is violence.’”

Amy Pondolfino, the Oneonta activist who attended with husband Tom and son Thomas, said, “I am peripherally aware there is racism in our area, but it doesn’t hurt me directly.” Even so, she was moved by the “very powerful stories.”

Cooperstown’s Mary Ann Whelan, the retired Bassett physician, expressed a similar reaction, but concluded, “It’s not always the system’s fault. First and foremost, individuals need to be held responsible.”

As for Benton, he said “protesting is super important and is part of the movement, but it isn’t accomplishing everything we need to accomplish – supporting the black economy, standing up against racism, not waiting for someone else to take action.”

As a first step, he’s joined the local chapter of the NAACP.

HAPPENIN’ OTSEGO: Cooperstown To Protest Racism, Police Brutality 06-07-20

Cooperstown To Protest

Racism, Police Brutality


PROTEST – 1 – 5 p.m. Come for a peaceful protest against the police violence that led to the death of George Floyd, raise money to support NAACP & ACLU. Be prepared to socially distance, wear your masks. Bring your friends, loved ones, and signs. All are welcome. Otsego County Courthouse, Cooperstown.

2nd Information Hearing Tonight On Creating County Manager Job

2nd Information Hearing Tonight

On Creating County Manager Job

COOPERSTOWN – The second public information hearing on Otsego County’s proposed county manager job is at 7 p.m. today at the county courthouse on upper Main street.  It is co-sponsored by the county board committee that developed the proposal and the League of Women voters.

The formal public hearing on the proposal will be at 9:30 a.m. Wednesday, Dec. 4, in the county board’s meeting room, 197 Main St., prior to the county reps’ monthly meeting.

Casey Callahan Gets 25-To-Life For Wife’s Murder



Man Found Guilty Of Killing Wife

By LIBBY CUDMORE • Special to

Casey Callahan on the first day of his trial. (Parker Fish/

COOPERSTOWN – Casey Callahan, 52, who was found guilty of the January 2000 murder of his wife Elizabeth Welsh in the county’s first murder trial in decades, was sentenced to 25-to-life by Judge John F. Lambert during his hearing yesterday on Otsego County Court.

“It’s the maximum sentence, and I’m satisfied,” said District Attorney John Muehl. “This was a cold, calculated, pre-meditated murder.”

“I ask the court to consider the magnitude and impact of this crime that took Elizabeth’s life and what it has done to her son and family,” said her sister, Marie Valentine, in a statement to the judge.  “I would ask your honor to consider sentencing Casey Callahan to the maximum sentence under the law, as any time he spends incarcerated is nothing compared to what he did to Elizabeth and what her family has and will experience in our lifetime.”





Casey Callahan

COOPERSTOWN – A jury this morning found Casey Callahan guilty of murder in the second degree for the Jan.19, 2000 death of his wife, Elizabeth Welsh Callahan.

The verdict came in around 11:30 a.m. District Attorney John Muehl prosecuted the case throughout the week, calling 21 witnesses. In the final hours of the trial yesterday morning, Callahan himself was called to the stand by his attorney, William Schebaum.


DAY ONE: Monday, Sept. 11

• IN OPENING REMARKS, District Attorney Muehl paraphrases suspect Callahan: “I can kill someone and get away with it.”

• TRUCK DRIVER George Borrowdale describes witnessing Callahan’s rig running over wife Elizabeth

Elizabeth’s Last Words: ‘I Love You’ Investigator Testifies

Victim’s Words Before Death,

Investigator Says: ‘I Love You’

COOPERSTOWN – Investigator Sean Ralph testified that Casey Callahan, currently on trial for the 2000 murder of his wife, Elizabeth Welsh Callahan, told him that her final words to her husband were “‘I love you, I’ll see you on the other side’,” allegedly referring to the opposite side of the Dandy Mart truck stop where Callahan was to pick her up.

Allegations of Physical Abuse Emerge in Niece’s Testimony


Allegations of Physical Abuse

Emerge in Niece’s Testimony

By PARKER FISH • Special to

COOPERSTOWN – Elizabeth Welsh Callahan allegedly told her niece, Amanda Travis, that her husband Casey Callahan had kicked her in the stomach while she was pregnant with their son, Connor.

“I didn’t like the way he treated Lizzy,” Travis said during her testimony as part of this afternoon’s proceedings in the case against Callahan, who is charged with Elizabeth’s murder.

Posts navigation

21 Railroad Ave. Cooperstown, New York 13326 • (607) 547-6103